Ask a Recruiter

Can’t Automate this: What’s Really Keeping the C-Suite Up at Night in Skilled Trades

I get a version of this question with almost every industrial client call now: “Any ideas on how we can recruit and retain our skilled trades?”

Wrong question. The right one is: who’s going to be running the floor in five years?

Here’s what’s actually sitting on the desks of CEOs, COOs, and CHROs at manufacturing and industrial companies right now — and it’s not quite the problem most people think it is.

Everyone’s heard the top-line number by now. The U.S. skilled trades workforce is short an estimated 1.3 million workers, and the gap isn’t closing.

  • More than a quarter of skilled-trades workers are 55 or older, and retirements now account for roughly 40% of all openings every year. That’s not a dip. It’s a wave, and it’s been building for a while.
  • 79% of manufacturing executives say the lack of skilled workers is their single biggest barrier to growth — ahead of tariffs, inflation, and supply chain risk combined.
  • Manufacturing floors are the hardest hit (90% of leaders say so), with operations and design/engineering close behind.
  • On paper, every open skilled-trades role has a few qualified people competing for it. In practice, the good ones already have three offers before your req is even posted.

None of that is news to anyone running a plant. What I’m not hearing discussed enough in the C-suite is the layer above the floor.

You can automate a welding cell. You can’t automate the plant manager who knows how to retain the welders you have left, redesign a shift schedule around an aging workforce, and build the apprenticeship pipeline that actually replaces people instead of just backfilling headcount. You can’t automate the HR leader who has to turn “we’re short-staffed” into an actual workforce strategy the board will fund.

That’s the real pain point. Companies are pouring money into robots and automation faster than they’re investing in the operations and HR leadership who can translate that investment into a workforce that still shows up on Monday.

I see it search after search: a plant-level or HR leadership role tied to a skilled-trades-heavy operation sits open two or three times longer than a comparable corporate role, because the person has to be fluent in both worlds — labor relations and logistics, succession planning and the shop floor, culture and cost-per-hire. That combination is rare, and it doesn’t show up by posting a job.

If you’re a CHRO or business leader reading this, and the honest answer to “who’s our bench for this role” is “we don’t really have one” — you’re not behind. Most of the industry is in the exact same spot. But the organizations that get ahead of it in the next 12 to 18 months, building real succession plans and bringing in leaders who’ve actually solved this before, are the ones who won’t be scrambling when the next wave of retirements hits.

So — what’s the real pain point in your organization right now: finding the trade workers, or finding the leader who can hold the workforce strategy together while that gap closes?

We are always happy to help you through every step of the process, from determining what your career goals are to helping you reach them. Feel free to contact us!

Visit the Ask a Recruiter Archives to get up to date on past issues!

If you have any questions, please feel free to ask here.

Contact Us

Find Us
Palm Coast, Florida

Call Us
386-986-2833